The Book Club of Two Presents:
Welcome! We’ve got an extra-special Book Club of Two this month. We’ve decided to be all literary and take on a re-read of Wuthering Heights. A book that I disliked the first 2 times around and RachelKiwi enjoyed but found it wasn’t her favorite.
Now we’re breaking it down 8 chapters at a time and asking all the tough questions like “Why is Lockwood such an idiot?!” Yep. The good stuff.
What makes this re-read even more special (besides the classic content) is that we’re joined by another childhood friend, LindszerWest. LindszerWest doesn’t have a blog so I’ll be posting her responses. But you may be asking yourself why we allowed her into this exclusive club for the re-read…Well, I’ll explain…
LindszerWest is not only a lifelong reader, she is a nook owning, bad-boy lover who saw the post announcing Wuthering Wednesdays and just had to jump in! Seriously, she was blasting my Facebook page with Heathcliff quotes *very fangirl*.
And while I’m making all these exceptions…I’ve decided to be nice to everyone for this re-read and instead of posting embarrassing pictures of awkward high school years I’m including pictures of us on our most beautiful day…Our wedding days 😉
TheLibrarian Answers
RachelKiwi’s Questions
My crush has shifted to Hareton. Compare and contrast Heathcliff and Hareton.
I think Hareton is slightly more mild as compared to Heathcliff. He doesn’t have the history of rejection that Heathcliff had. I think (for better or worse) the knowledge that Hareton is born to a family with a name and a history hold Hareton back from becoming as strictly hurtful as Heathcliff.
Reflecting back on something The Librarian commented on in Week One: Nelly does interfere a little bit in the story. Does this make you trust her less? Should we blame her? Or was she justified in her occasional meddling?
Well, if we are to believe Nelly was as close to everything as she claims to be I don’t think she can help but meddle a bit…both in the past story and in the current retelling. Nelly has her own motivations and her own bias. Her love of Catherine (2), the softness she sees in the girl stems more from raising the girl rather than a clear view of Catherine’s actual nature.
Still if we are to trust anyone on the moors she’s our best bet. She seems to have found a weakness on all sides at one point or another. Not a great narrator…but it’s a wacky story anyway. What fun would it be if our narrator was trustworthy? That person would have escaped the moors long ago.
Is Cathy Linton Catherine Earnshaw all over again?
She’s pretty darn close. Though she seems to have had a better childhood so I suppose we can’t judge her fully. Catherine (2) was never allowed to run wild as Catherine (1) was.
TheLibrarian’s Questions
Linton
Which characters from the previous generation is Linton most like?
Ok, how the heck did we get Linton from the past generation. I suppose, as insinuated by his name, he got a lot of Linton in him. But seriously, every other character had a backbone…passion…something. Linton is just a wimp.
What differences does Linton have from the previous generations?
Uhm, his wimpy-ness. He just isn’t as motivated by passion as they were.
What part does Linton play in the present?
He gives everyone someone to use against one another. And honestly Bronte wouldn’t have been happy without her little love triangle. Linton just isn’t as attractive as Edgar was in the generation previous.
Catherine (2)
Which characters from the previous generation is Catherine (2) most like?
Of all the children Catherine (2) is most a combination of her parents. I think she seems more like Catherine, but Nelly would have us believe that she maintains a softness from her father. Something in me finds this suspect…I think Nelly is feeding us a little bit of a line through her lens of having raised Catherine (2) and the fact that she disliked Catherine (1).
But I think at this point I may be getting a bit cynical 😉
What differences does Catherine (2) have from the previous generations?
Perhaps it was raising her in isolation. But Catherine is simply more temperate in all things. She’s willing to re-evaluate her relationships. She’s not as carried off by passion…for better or worse. She’s suspect of marriage in general. Catherine is the most realistic of characters out on the moors. I think she could have broken away from it all; had she been set in another book. But the moors takes no prisoners. You know Catherine (2) is heading toward some twisted stuff…it’s not going to end well…
What part does Catherine (2) play in the present?
She’s the center of the love triangle. Literally the center of everyone’s eyes. True this makes her a bit of a pawn…but I think because she’s so much like her mother it torments Heathcliff a bit. And you know that man deserves a bit of torture…Catherine (1) did promise to haunt him from the grave. Little did Heathcliff know it would be her living daughter. Not that this will save Catherine (2). Nope, it’s just firmly cementing her as a tool for Heathcliff.
Hareton
Which characters from the previous generation is Hareton most like?
Heathcliff! Seriously, even Heathcliff agrees that he actually likes Hareton. If only Hareton wasn’t a person Heathcliff had set out to ruin…
How the heck Bronte had Hindley and Frances produce this one is beyond me…Makes the least sense of all the children.
What differences does Hareton have from the previous generations?
Really, had he been an orphan he seriously would have been Heathcliff word for word. I suppose having the history of a family…having been raised with a father [not well obviously…don’t we all remember the baby dangling incident…] gave Hareton the pride that Heathcliff was missing. Where Heathcliff was driven by anger based on revenge, Hareton is driven by anger based on pride.
What part does Hareton play in the present?
He’s the hottie! And he’s apparently Heathcliff’s child via strangers…weird. And Heathcliff will ruin him too, just ’cause.
Bonus: Could anyone in this new generation live a happy life? Who would you bet on and why?
For sure Catherine (2) but really no one is making it out of the moors. Lets be honest, to even think of any of these characters living happy is a false hope…makes me kinda sad…
LindzerWest Answers
RachelKiwi’s Questions
My crush has shifted to Hareton. Compare and contrast Heathcliff and Hareton.
Ah, Hareton. Like Heathcliff, he’s disowned and forced to work in the fields, but he has it much worse as he SHOULD rightfully be the master of Wuthering Heights. As a result of the abuse he receives from Heathcliff and the teasing he gets from Cathy and Linton, he’s every bit as sullen as Heathcliff was as a boy. However, he seems to have a more charitable spirit, as we know that he never touches Linton no matter how much he provokes him, and Hareton also does his best to improve himself in the only ways he knows how. So yes, Hareton and Heathcliff are both disowned, disenfranchised souls, but Hareton doesn’t seem to carry the same evil intentions for his oppressors as Heathcliff does.
Reflecting back on something The Librarian commented on in Week One: Nelly does interfere a little bit in the story. Does this make you trust her less? Should we blame her? Or was she justified in her occasional meddling?
Nelly meddles a lot in the story, as she often comes out looking like a saint in the retelling (and appears to be the voice of reason throughout). If I’d nurses such a succession of loonies though, I’d probably spiff up my own supposed virtues in the retelling too…
Is Cathy Linton Catherine Earnshaw all over again?
Yes and no. Unlike Catherine Earnshaw, Cathy Linton actually has some compassion for others and selflessly nurses both her father and Nelly Dean while they are ill. She says “I fret about nothing on earth except papa’s illness” and wishes to make Linton happy — but she is like her mother in that most of these actions serve her too — her kindness in looking after Edgar and Nelly is partly prompted by her fear of what would happen to her if they died, and she nurses Linton because she considers him a pretty little pet and amusing to her. And the scene where she teases Hareton for his ignorance is pure Catherine Earnshaw.
TheLibrarian’s Questions
Linton
Which characters from the previous generation is Linton most like?
Edgar Linton, in his Milquetoast-esque, wimpy demeanor. I can’t see any of Heathcliff in him at all, except for the one time he flies into a passion at Hareton.
What differences does Linton have from the previous generations?
Unlike the previous generation, he doesn’t have the capacity for long-term revenge – maybe because he knows he’s not long for the world.
What part does Linton play in the present?
Basically, he’s a pawn for Heathcliff’s ongoing revenge, and serves only to keep the two households at war.
Catherine (2)
Which characters from the previous generation is Catherine (2) most like?
She is like her mother in that most of her actions toward others are motivated by her own losses and gains, but she has her father’s mildness. She reminds me of Isabella in many ways.
What differences does Catherine (2) have from the previous generations?
She seems as though she’s the most adaptable to the real world – had Heathcliff not engineered a relationship between Catherine and Linton, she probably would have married some nice man from the village and been mostly happy.
What part does Catherine (2) play in the present?
Unfortunately, she’s a pawn, just like Linton. The two of them serve as the connectors between the two ill-fated households.
Hareton
Which characters from the previous generation is Hareton most like?
He’s Heathcliff in his anger and Catherine Earnshaw in his pride. Seriously, did someone switch the bassinets?
What differences does Hareton have from the previous generations?
Although he can be angry and sullen, Hareton doesn’t seem to have the same capacity for lifelong grudges.
What part does Hareton play in the present?
He serves as a daily reminder to Heathcliff of what he COULD have had in a son — “I’d have loved the lad had he been someone else” — but I think he has another role to play as well.
Bonus: Could anyone in this new generation live a happy life? Who would you bet on and why?
I think they’re all too thoroughly addled by the moors by now, but see my answer about Catherine Linton, above. I think she’s normal/boring enough to pass in normal society, and could have married out of the insanity.
Remember to Check Out RachelKiwi’s blog for her thoughts…she’s always much funnier 😉
Read Full Post »