Welcome to the Book Club of Two
One of my best friends from High School (RachelKiwi…the one on the right) happens to share my own addictive love of reading…She even owns a Nook and everything so we share and trade and do lots of texting about bookish things while we should be working. Every so many weeks we get an itch and decide to do a book together. Our reading abilities are about the same so there’s no problem with finishing the text in a day or two…we both read that fast. Since RachelKiwi is a great gal I thought I’d give you guys a little peek into our exclusive club 😉
We did The Last Letter from your Lover awhile back and had this massive rambling conversation about it…feel free to follow along. As a warning there are *SPOILERS* because it’s not a good breakdown unless you’re spilling the dirt!
If you’d like to read a review instead you can find RachelKiwi’s Here and Mine Here.
Without further Ado…The Convo…
*Spoilers*
The Librarian: This book’s plot had so many twists and turns…missed chances…did you ever guess correctly? Was there a time when you were way off?
RachelKiwi: The missed chances killed me! I was breathing erratically half the time I read this, wanting to jump into the book and intervene to bring the lovers together. My guesses were off… probably because I’m always swept along on the wings of romance, because I’m basically a hopeless-romantic-on-steroids. I hoped that Jennifer’s child was Anthony’s… even though the dates were way off for that to be the case! But I was totally blown away by the fact that there was a child. I didn’t see that coming and being the reason she couldn’t run off with Anthony. I thought that maybe Jennifer and Laurence couldn’t have children, because the issue of kids came up several times.
The things I suspected: I knew there was something fishy about the car crash, because of Laurence’s reaction to it every time they discussed it. I don’t think I ever really believed Anthony had died in it, though. And I wondered what Moira’s role was in the story. She seemed like such a peripheral character, until she reappeared to provide the means for Jennifer to leave her husband.
What about you? Were you surprised or did you have some things figured out? What did you think about the entrance of the new storyline/characters in Part III? At first I was distracted by it, but then I ended up liking what it added.
The Librarian: I was constantly surprised by the twists! The baby surprised me, that she followed him to Africa got me. Though I wasn’t shocked that Anthony wasn’t in The Congo…I thought the secretary at the news room gave that away. Also, I guessed that Anthony was the librarian…it was odd that Ellie didn’t know his name after she mentions not knowing the staff names and begins to pay more attention. Oh, my other shock was that Anthony’s ex-wife died, I though the cancer was a little rushed. Even a quick cancer death still would have been weeks in the making, Anthony would have been informed earlier. Moyes should have gone with some type of accident.
Ok, part 3 came out of NOWHERE for me! Lol, I swear I thought the synopsis said that a modern-day writer finds the letter and through all the first part of the book I kept waiting for one of those time changes to hit 2003…I was distracted by the expectation of it..Then , BAM Part 3. When it finally hit I was almost annoyed. Ellie’s love seemed shallow and annoying and why she didn’t just hit up Rory was beyond me. But then I did grow to like her and I loved meeting Jennifer again, hearing the rest of the story… *sigh* …cried at the park scene…
Have you ever been totally distracted by love like Ellie and Jennifer? And have you ever received a love letter? (dear John letter perhaps, lol)
RachelKiwi: I totally didn’t see that the librarian was Anthony. I just wondered why they kept making references to the fact that she didn’t know names and that he was such a great guy. So yeah, I was really surprised when his son said that Anthony still worked there… and had for 40 years. Oops!
Yes, i loved Rory. he sounded great! Did you notice she didn’t do much with physical descriptions for anyone? I wanted to know what Ellie and Rory looked like. She didn’t describe Anthony either. Jennifer got the most description, we know she’s beautiful with blonde hair and “deliquescent” eyes. I looked that word up. I thought it was interesting how she threw herself into going after her lover and thought it was Reggie. And that word was what made her realize that he couldn’t possibly be her lover.
I thought Jennifer aged so well… so dignified. I loved the park scene too. anyway…
Distracted by love? of course! I blame Nathan for my lowest GPA of my life… the semester we started dating in college. And of course, I did have the raging hormones and obsessive crushes in high school. A relationship can consume you completely if you let it, and Ellie let it happen to her in a bad way. The beginning of love is always intoxicating, but I think you have to stay grounded, which Anthony and Jennifer managed to do even in the wake of passion and devastation. Ellie lost herself to her relationship, whereas A and J found themselves and got stronger, even through pain. I was almost out of patience with Ellie for her pathetic devotion to an idiot.
And I remember the first letter Nathan ever sent me, I practically memorized it and almost slept with it under my pillow. And read between the lines, just as Jennifer and Ellie do. Although Jennifer didn’t really need to read between the lines… Anthony laid his heart bare. I can’t imagine getting a “last letter” though.
i was gonna ask you this next:
What was the impact of Anthony’s letters on Jennifer’s life? On Anthony’s life?
I was intrigued by the fact that even though she had amnesia, in reading the letters, she yearned for the writer of them. They made her believe in love, that someone out there loved her, and that she allowed to herself to be loved in a beautiful way.
It was interesting how she “couldn’t find words” for so much of their relationship, and then at the end, he lost his. Symbolizing her strength, that she found herself and her words? And that he had lost so much, felt so much pain at not being able to be with the woman he loved that he lost his faculty with writing?
The Librarian: The fast progression of the relationship didn’t bother me. I think that both of them were wounded by their choices in life, and in love. Both characters seemed to be floating through their lives…not really happy with anything. So when they found that connection they jumped on it. Plus I think there’s always something to be said about the forbidden aspect of the love. That always pushes things along faster. Like latching on to a crush in high school (you really did have a few major crushes!) it seems so enormously part of your mind, your thoughts because you really can’t have it so you begin to obsess over it. I suppose this rule goes for Ellie too. She can’t let John go because he’s what she can’t have. She knows she can have Rory so she lets him sit on the side untouched…kind of like a second choice.
As for the impact of the letters on Jennifer’s life. I think that their love had a better chance after the accident than before. Seeing her options, either stay with her husband or move onto Anthony, without the filter of her previous life choices just throws onto display how bad a match Larry is for her. I think when you’ve played a role for so long…faking the marriage with Larry till they make it, it’s hard to let go of the weight of it. With the amnesia Jennifer can clearly see the right choice and go for it. Had she not had the accident I think their love affair would have ended.
So after a book-long quest for love…Do you think Moyes ended it well? Did the end live up to the letter’s expectations?
RachelKiwi: no comment on the adolescent crushes. I claim insanity.
I don’t know. she clearly was trying to leave larry to be with Anthony when the accident happened. i mean, larry humiliated her and berated her. she knew she wasn’t happy with larry–amnesia or no. but you’re right, i think the years of separation that the accident caused made both of them realize the importance of that relationship. to Anthony, Jennifer was irreplaceable, and Jennifer was mourning the loss of a man she loved and barely remembered. so when they were reunited, it was that much more powerful of an experience.
the ending:
the last reunion: i liked how the reader doesn’t hear what the two lovers are saying… we see it through Ellie’s eyes, so we see only a touch. it’s too private a moment for us to “eavesdrop” on. it was a very satisfying ending, everything wrapped up neatly and happily-ever-after for all those involved. after years of missed chances, they finally connect. sometimes there is something secretly pleasurable in an ending where the lovers are torn apart by life and never get their happily-ever-after. sometimes it seems that to be real, a book has to end with that kind of sundering. but in this case, their entire adult lives had been lived separately, so a happy ending was very satisfying.
I kinda love the story of a playboy who never thinks he’ll settle down, until he meets the one woman who cures him of his philandering ways. i was nervous at first to read Anthony’s letters, knowing Jennifer was falling hook-line-and-sinker for the flowery words of a notorious womanizer. but he meant them. His love and longing for her survived distance and separation. The story’s happily-ever-after lived up to the letter’s promises.
Read Full Post »